Monday, January 9, 2023

Fumble at the Fifty ?

Overnight the ES futures were higher after only a very shallow retrace. As a result, the cash SPY opened with a gap upward. After opening higher, prices traded higher until about 11 AM. Then, on as light a volume downward as cash prices made their upward move, they began heading downward to ultimately close the gap before the close. The SPY daily chart is below.

SPY Cash - Daily - Spinning Top Candle?

Three things can be noted:

  1. Today's candle qualifies as a "spinning top" candle but needs closing lower validation.
  2. The SPY got up to the resistance of the prior November lows, crossed the 50% Fib & 50 SMA.
  3. The MACD has not crossed above the zero line yet.
So, first things first. Let's see if the high of this daily candle holds, and if gets a substantial closing lower candle. If so, the next step would be to see if the December low is exceeded lower. If so, it may be possible to get a 1.618 wave because the potential wave ii up exceeded the 50% level - at least in cash. Then see if the MACD crosses lower beneath the zero line again.

In a similar situation with Gold (GC) futures which made a higher high and a doji on the upper daily Bollinger Band.

This would seem to be a good time to pay close attention to these markets. Have a great start to the evening.

TraderJoe

16 comments:

  1. Joe, I would be hesitant to call today's candle a spinning top given the lack of any lower wick. I would classify it as a shooting star which makes a stronger statement towards a reversal as compared to the indecision of a spinning top. However, both signals require a confirmation bar so it puts the assessment of the market in the same position either way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I accept your analysis. A lot of the examples for the shooting star showed the gap remaining open at the end of the day, so I chose not to go that route. But, you can be correct here, too. TJ.

      Delete
  2. How are you counting the 'ii' wave? a (3) - b (3) - c(5)? Today (after 11 am) looked like a 4 of 'c'. QQQ is up 15 points over two days (3 of 'c' ?), gave back 5 pts this afternoon for a 1/3 retrace. It's close to oversold on the 30-min RSI & SloSto.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Personal opinion (largely based on measurement) is there was indeed a triangle in the mix - one that pointed upwards and not downwards. The usual technical target for a triangle is shown by the arrows (widest-width of the triangle added to the breakout point). Pretty darn close.

      https://www.tradingview.com/x/YrLR9kvf/

      TJ

      Delete
    2. Thanks. Interesting. Complicated correction.

      Delete
  3. Thanks TJ. Regarding this - "If so, it may be possible to get a 1.618 wave because the potential wave ii up exceeded the 50% level - at least in cash."

    Is this guideline in the Frost & Prechter book?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is explained on page 136 of that book in a poor way saying, "when wave 1 is the extended wave, then it is wave 2 that quite naturally often divides the wave into the Golden Section". By converse reasoning then, if wave 1 is going to be the extended wave, then wave 2 is often only 38.2% or less. So, IF wave 2 is 'greater than' 38.2%, the odds increase that wave 3 or 5 will be the extended wave in the sequence.

      Neely says it much more explicitly on page 11-2 of Mastering Elliott Wave. For Trending Waves, "When wave 1 is the extended wave, then wave 2 'cannot' retrace much more than 38.2% of wave 1." Lower left of page. And again on page 11-3, for Wave 2: "If wave 1 turns out to be the extended wave, then wave 2 can not retrace much more than 38.2% of wave 1". Whereas for Wave 1 not-extended, then wave 2 can retrace up to 99% of wave 1. Therefore, by simple logic, the "odds increase that wave 3 or 5 is the extended wave, if wave 2 is greater than 38.2%" - like the 50% we just saw in the SPY. TJ.

      Delete
  4. Reminder: Chair Powell scheduled to speak at the top of the hour (Reuters). TJ.

    ReplyDelete
  5. SPY 15-min: this ((A))-((B))-((C)) flat might avoid failure, or it might not.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/A5upOx95/

    Volume is still pretty punk, and the waves whippy.
    TJ

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. From what I can see, max for a diagonal would be 3,942.00 futures. TJ.

      Delete
    2. ES / SPY wave above prior morning high. Did not fail. TJ.

      Delete
    3. SPY 15-min: only if price again goes up over the high of the diagonal, then the diagonal 'might' be leading, and wave red ((1)) moves to the low.

      https://www.tradingview.com/x/AfnyoMJL/

      TJ

      Delete
    4. TJ if diagonal exceeded, does that mean ES will rally higher above monday's highs of 3,972

      Delete
    5. @Jim .. possible to make a deeper retrace on ES more towards 50% or 62% in ES futures. But, not required. TJ.

      Delete
  6. A new post is started for the next day.
    TJ

    ReplyDelete