Monday, October 26, 2026

Crying Over Spilt Milk

This post explains, in part, why I designed The Principle of Equivalence for financial markets. There is another reason, too, but I will leave that for later. This example is from the current US500 equity index. Two panels of four-hour charts are below. We know the market has traveled lower a bit - it has spilt some milk.

US500 CFD - 4 Hr - Two Logical Interpretations

As you can see from the left panel, it is possible to count the current wave structure as a series of three wave structures which might eventually go on to complete a contracting diagonal. Please ignore the degree of the labels for the moment. They are just for relative size illustration at this time. In the left panel you can see that purple 3 is shorter in price and time than purple 1. So, to complete this count, the wave structure needs a 4 that is shorter than 2, and a 5 that is shorter than 3, hopefully in three-wave sequences. The potential wave 4 already overlaps the potential wave 1, so that part of the job is already done. The MACD is diverging, so that could fit, too.

But now look on the right panel. It is also possible to consider the truncation at the red asterisk (*) shown, followed by an impulse for the first wave, blue 1. Then, in a parallel, there is a second wave, 2, followed by a smaller degree blue wave i. Because this wave is shorter in price & time than the larger degree wave 1, then we are allowed to also consider a nested count for a down move. And there might be an expanded flat brewing for the smaller-degree second wave ii. It is currently shorter in time than the larger wave 2.

So, there you have it. I'll bet you think it is pretty spiffy that two different counts can potentially work with all their wave degrees in-tact. Every wave that needs to be longer is longer. Every wave that needs to be shorter is shorter - and this is in both price and time. A purple count and a blue count. So, you'd be doing anything but crying over that spilt milk, right? You know what to do in either one of two cases, right?

No, a key reason why I designed the Principle of Equivalence is because of the chart below. Same panel on the left. Different panel on the right.


The count in the right panel is still a truncation count. But because the brown x wave shown is also shorter in price and time than brown 1, then it is potentially legitimate that the market is making an even larger second wave, 2. This wave could be in the overall flat variety. It could turn out to be a regular flat wave, a "running flat" wave that does not cross over the w wave, or even an expanded flat wave to make a deeper second wave, 2.

And this is a key reason why The Principle of Equivalence was designed. "With the current state of prices available to us at this time, there are literally three possibilities which, if prices were random, could each occur". Not two, three! That means there are roughly equal odds of the outcomes - purple, blue and brown - and those odds are roughly 33% each.

I have showed you intraday where examples with 3% or 4% odds routinely happen. So, are roughly-equal 33% odds anything to stake a claim on? I suggest not. It would be gambling at the very least, and maybe just plain irresponsible, especially with an FOMC meeting, more earnings, and probably POTUS war or peace tweets in the near future.

No, this is why I implore readers here to measure, measure, measure both price and time to see what fits in with various degrees of waves (which waves are actually larger and which waves are actually smaller) and remain patient and flexible until the situation clears.

To be truthful, I watched one veteran wave-counter's YouTube video this weekend and I watched him agonize how sloppy the market was, and what it was doing to the fund he runs. I mean he was almost crying on-line about how useless the wave principle was and how no counts currently fit his currently uber bullish scenario.

Rather than agonize, I long-ago developed a full-fledged equivalence principle that tells me what I must do in such situations, and why. It is not because of darned Elliott Wave. It is because there is a principle of wave counting that says, "lengths of price & lengths of time actually MATTER". And, like throwing a rock in a lake, you just don't know how big or small the waves will be until you either see them, or until you see the size of the pebble or boulder than goes into the water. 

Yes, from an investing or trading perspective, you want like the dickens to know how big those waves will be in the future. But, in actuality, all you have is odds. So, act accordingly until things become more clear.

Have an excellent rest of the evening,

TraderJoe


15 comments:

  1. I think you'll get a better downward channel by connecting the lows, rather than the highs. This would be reversed in an upward channel of course. The lows are leading the way. https://www.tradingview.com/x/hf0rr5mb/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're not incorrect, but not correct, either. The problem is (as shown above), we don't 'know' because of the massive retrace of that second wave off the ATH, that the first wave down is part of the sequence. It very well could be, thus your channel. But in the impulse/truncation count, it does not have to be part of that channel. TJ.

      Delete
    2. It's a widely accepted charting process, to connect bottoms in a downtrend, and vice versa in an uptrend (even over shorter time-frames). For now, my upper trendline has held the price rally: https://www.tradingview.com/x/94JfVYgS/

      Delete
    3. Except, that is not Elliott's technique. For the 'base channel' Elliott says, "draw a line from 0 to 2, and connect a parallel to 1." And your suggested channel did not hold in the final analysis, as shown below.

      https://www.tradingview.com/x/RDvHf4zs/

      All that suggests to me is we don't know where 2 is yet. That's why we measure, and measure, and measure.
      TJ

      Delete
  2. Thanks Tj. Whenever you get time please explain this running triangle viability as once you said thr is a way this can be counted. This is for learning purpose only

    https://www.neowave.com/tradingblog/blog.asp?bid=186

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. Stop linking to neowave. 2. I never said anything about neowave's running triangle. 3. Stop bugging me about Neely's count. TJ

      Delete
  3. A complete Masterwork, TraderJoe! 🎨
    Thank you for sharing your detailed analysis. 💎

    One cannot even buy better traditional Elliott Wave S&P 500 wave counting than yours.

    ReplyDelete
  4. TJ, Could this diagonal be expanding in time that we are making the 4 on Sundays post?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ..just barely possible IFF the roll-over contract makes a new low. So, it is possible with slightly less odds. TJ.

      Delete
  5. SPY (cash) 15-min: could be seen to have five-waves-up, off the low, as follows.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/7i4BcK5A/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  6. Here's a thought bubble which I would like to invite feedback on:
    (and my apologies TJ, if you have already described this possibility better than I am doing so here) 😅

    What if: what we are seeing as "corrections" in the S&P 500 Index is simply a case of cascading 4th waves of smaller and smaller degree (within a larger degree extended 5th wave), as this unprecedented "Bull Market" momentum slows, interest rates float higher, and the previous big-cap market leading stocks begin larger corrections?

    In other words, each time we have seen a potential "top", what we really got is actually a confusing mess of a triangle - which turns out to only be a stopping point on the march to new market highs. I can count these back to 2018...

    But focusing on the present moment, this would explain the failure of the December S&P 500 E-mini contract to make a new high, while the S&P 500 Cash Index made a nominal new high.

    A simple chart would place Friday 23 October's low as the < end of a C wave / beginning of a D wave > with at least one more new high on the horizon:

    https://postimg.cc/xXgsL0Rx

    ReplyDelete
  7. A new post is start for the next day.
    TJ

    ReplyDelete