Saturday, October 31, 2026

Tricky Treats

As I stated in prior postings, no amount of downward movement will be a surprise. We got only a typical smaller portion, Halloween-sized, morsel of that on Friday, and then a rebound. The most ghastly of facts surrounding this decline is that my proprietary bullish sentiment model shows the percent bullishness as still being on the longest average sustained romp over the 60% level that has ever been recorded by this measure, as shown in the weekly chart below, as of this weekend. 

Bullish Sentiment - Weekly - Longest Ever Sustained Push Over 60%


Now for a real fright: compare that level to that shown on the CNN Money Fear & Greed Index, shown below.



This, market-basket approach, is showing outright fear and labels it as such. The indicator-basket is made up of a mishmash of moving averages on a number of factors, and it's trying to tell you people are thinking differently than the survey data, above. Quite honestly, I've looked over their indicators and to me they are confusing with the overall index ill-constructed. So this may amount to an unintentional but never-the-less nasty Trick being played on you - much like when the high-school kids on Halloween night think they're only going to flood your window-well with the garden hose, but instead the whole basement gets drenched.

We know that daily price now has a lower high (or a series of them) and now a lower low. So, does the market offer any costumes that might be more informative, and not just hip & cool? Well, for that we turn to the work of Master Trader, Bill Williams. Bill wrote the book Trading Chaos and offered some indicators that are still in wide use today. A few of them are used in the chart below. They are 1) the Alligator, 2) the Elliott Wave Oscillator, or AO, and 3) fractals.


The first thing one can note is that the truncation high, if it remains so, did occur on a confirmed divergence with the Elliott Wave Oscillator as shown in the bottom panel. That divergence is given the term confirmed precisely because there was a daily higher price high on a lower EWO value, and then the EWO dropped below zero again.

The next thing to note is in the upper right - the presence of a trap fractal. That is defined as a price that exceeded a prior fractal, in this case, green or up, and then promptly reversed to exceed a fractal in the opposite direction, in this case a red or down fractal.

So, think about the characteristics of either 2nd waves or of B waves. Their job is to try to convince you that the trend prior to the last wave is really reversing. In other words, you didn't see a 1 wave or an A wave, down, in this case, before the 2 wave or B wave up. No, that down wave was a sham, a ghost, as it literally didn't happen. That is what the trap fractal tries to do. It tries to get you to buy into the reversal back into the prior up trend at precisely the incorrect time.

So, in the Bill Williams system, there is now a fractal break well below the alligator. Several down (red) fractals have been broken lower. And the daily gator appears to be turning lower. And, while this is a sell signal in the Bill Williams system, keep in mind, as I have written about before, to follow this system on a daily basis requires a very high level of capitalization relative to risk. So, what that means is one either has to be extremely wealthy already not to care about the inevitable retracements relative to one's potential market gains, or one has to remain out of the market until one of those retraces occurs, or one has to keep their position sizes extremely small (in either futures or options, say) until the gator fully "opens up" to the downside. In short, extremely conscientious risk-management must be practiced or the consequences might be suffered.

Lastly, should the market continue lower the chart is showing the first two price counts along the way, noting that the 2.618 Fibonacci level is also a measured move should the neckline of this bobblehead be significantly broken lower.

Have a terrifying, hair-raising, and blood-curdling rest of the weekend - just kidding, of course.

TraderJoe


39 comments:

  1. Some of us over the years have cynically cited the "Working Group" to explain some of the most unlikely and unexpected market price action, and no doubt justifiably so. It will be interesting to see how they fare when AI driven HFTA inevitably switch from " Buy the Dip" to "Sell the Rip". What I find absolutely astonishing about your sentiment indicator readings is that it would remain so bullish in the current Geo-Economic, Geo-Political maelstrom the entire Globe is facing. What is truly unsettling about that is that Working Group or no Working Group, it is Prima Facie evidence that the Herd is clueless, or worse stupid. So much for efficient markets!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. MPAI Tachy, I even have a client who has made c. 250% in the portfolio I provide my clients over the past two years, he decided to stick £50k into tech stocks this year, he's already down by 20%, and I have been telling clients for well over a year it's going to collapse in a heap. I am bemused as to why he did it. I think the 'working group' pump it AND dump it, ultimately they desire the collapse of the USD, so many prior instances of this through the ages.

      Delete
    2. I have been waiting for some big years for last 20 years.mr precther (spelling) favorite mantra 20 years ago was to stock up food etc because of the upcoming calamity, and since then then sp went from 600 to 8000. So i dont know what is right or wrong. Even if you had bought so at 1500 and rode it to 600, today you'd be sitting at 7600.

      Delete
    3. You make some very valid points. Anyone bearish the last several years and not nimble enough to scalp the declines got slammed. Having said that, the current situation is unprecedented. This last leg of the rally has been driven almost exclusively by tech. They are becoming cash flow negative. PE multiple expansion via massive share buybacks a subterfuge no longer tenable. The loss of 20% daily Global Oil supply guarantees rampant inflationary forces rippling through every sector of the economy as Oil and particularly Diesel is the life-blood of the Global economy. With persistent inflation the tool Central Banks love is stymied. No Q.E. No Operation Twist. True demand destruction might mitigate the carnage, but carnage there will be...even a blind person can see this!

      Delete
    4. US govt maximum income comes from capital gains. They hv to keep the markets up to run the show. Fed will follow qe and cut rates if markets fall more than 20%. US is a service based economy and China manufacturing. They need each other to grow. No currency yet to replace usd so just print.

      Delete
    5. Tachy, I have been bearish the past few years, but rather than risk it with the big indices, I just went with GDX. Happy days. mm, the fedgov can and does create money from thin air, they don't need taxes. The Fed and other central banks will print, because their plan is to destroy the current currencies (except the supranational euro). CBDCs are their plan. A little deflationary crash is what they want now I believe.

      Delete
    6. Smart choice. It was still possible to make some very nice coin with a bearish bent the last few years, as long as you were nimble. Thank God for credit spreads! ;)

      Delete
    7. no, mm. you are spouting garbage. The largest portion is wages & other sources like "interest income, dividends, etc." Why do you do this, and say things which can clearly & easily be shown as incorrect?

      "Capital gains amount to 5% to 10% of total U.S. individual income tax revenues in a typical year, though the exact portion fluctuates significantly based on stock market and economic performance."

      You do this & you want me to make movies for you? You must be joking.

      TJ

      Delete
  2. Thanks tj. I miss your audio posts. Do whenever possible.

    ReplyDelete
  3. SPX500 (CFD) 10-min: this morning shows how bullish people 'really' are, buying with abandon while the daily bias is still lower.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/2N9TJajO/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In both the S&P 500 Cash Index and the S&P 500 E-Mini Dec '26 (ESZ26) futures, this rebound (since the Friday 30 October low) has now overlapped the lows of "wave a/i".

      I'm not certain what this means for the "Main Truncation Count", but I think this rebound cannot be an impulsive wave 4 (only a wave 4 in a diagonal). 🤔

      Delete
    2. @HG .. you may be incorrectly assessing which wave group this belongs to, as below. Remember, I said on Friday that ⑤ of iii was the extended wave in the sequence. That means 'it is likely to be retraced 'at least 62%, and possibly fully retraced'.

      https://www.tradingview.com/x/a2XFNkHE/

      TJ

      Delete
    3. I see exactly what you are saying, TJ. Thank you for the clarification! 👍

      Delete
  4. The long tail on Friday's candle suggesting the merriment might persist for a few days, lol!

    ReplyDelete
  5. SPY (cash) 10-min: now below the cash open and into the gap.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/fdGo8hDs/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  6. Someone please tell the one thing we know 'definitively' at this time from the ES 4-hr chart. TJ.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. which triangle? (not what I was thinking)

      Delete
    2. Price is below the 18-period Moving Average.

      Delete
    3. Yeah, but Nah. We 'know' from the shaded boxes shown that 5 = 1 will not make a new low.

      https://www.tradingview.com/x/6dPczbtc/

      THEREFORE, the primary way to make a lower low is a 5 = 0.618 x net (1-to-3)
      or longer. We know this clearly, and it is very, very useful.

      TJ

      Delete
    4. ...and the only remaining way to make a 5 = 1 would be if 4 were to turn into a triangle so that the measurement from the (e) wave of the triangle was 5 = 1.
      We know this clearly. So, if a triangle does not form, then look for the target above. TJ.

      Delete
    5. @Jack, 16 September 2026 lows were broken in S&P 500 E-Mini Dec '26 (ESZ26) futures, but not in the S&P 500 Cash Index.

      This low could conceivably count as a "c" wave in a "running 4th wave triangle" from a 3rd wave high on 02 June 2026. 🤔

      If this scenario is correct, price has to rally NOW in a 5th wave, as there are only 20 S&P 500 Cash Index points below the Friday, 20 October 2026 lows and the 16 September 2026 lows.

      Delete
  7. SPY (cash) 10-min: into five non-overlapping waves down, with an extended wave x①. Watch out for a second wave at some point.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/vCRRad3A/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  8. No first of the day money no more.

    ReplyDelete
  9. "Buy, when there's blood in the streets" - Baron Rothschild

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello Tj

    Thanks for all your profound and dedicated work to try and teach us to measure and count!
    Much appreciated

    If I understand you correctly, I think 1 of 5 ended this morning around 7515, so now 2 up of 5 of iii down is no forming and should bring us back between 7.570 - 7.585 – 7.620 somwhere?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi koba, no I didn't say 1 of 5 ended this morning at 7515. That is because I also spoke earlier about the possibility of a triangle here. It is possible a triangle could also resolve the discrepancy between futures having made a lower low, and cash not. Must still wait for a bit. TJ.

      Delete
  11. SPX500 (CFD) 30-min: up to combination of daily pivot, upper Bollinger Band, and 100-MA, then backing off.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/ZLKEddQf/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  12. I see some gaps overhead in the S&P 500 Cash Index chart. Including a huge approximately 50 point + gap from 29 October to 30 October.

    There is also an ascending trendline running from the lows of 29 July 2026 & 16 September 2026. If this market rallies, I would look for a target of closing the huge gap, which should just about challenge this broken trendline.

    ReplyDelete
  13. SPX500 (CFD) 30-min: and back to the 18-per intraday in still whippy price action.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/Udd213gg/

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  14. SPY (cash) 1-hr: nothing significant yet. Futures likely settled on the 18-per intraday.

    https://www.tradingview.com/x/P5iaHPNq/

    The daily bias of the futures still remains lower.

    TJ

    ReplyDelete
  15. A new post is started for the next day.
    TJ

    ReplyDelete