Back several months ago now, on May 2, I said it would be interesting to follow the progress of HYG (High Yield Bond Fund ETF) to see how well it might act as a leading indicator of US Equity prices, then as measured by the SPY ETF. You can view the post at this LINK. Today, now that everyone, or almost everyone, recognizes a down-turn in progress, we'll have a look at how well this indicator did. Remember, the rationale behind treating this as a leading indicator was that the largest and perhaps most sophisticated investors who were willing to hold this ETF, which holds some of the riskiest debt, might start sensing dangers in the waters and seek to exit first. If you reference the first chart in that original post, you'll see that the daily MACD is on a high, and above zero, although the histogram of the MACD is declining. Here is the first of the follow-up charts, the weekly chart of the SPY (Cash) Daily, with the HYG close plotted along with it.
![]() |
| SPY (Cash) - Weekly - vs HYG ETF |
The observations from this weekly chart are clearly that, since the original post, HYG kept diverging from the higher SPY prices until the turn of the SPY ETF in September. Second, we will note the HYG is still declining on a weekly basis, and it has made a lower closing weekly low than the late March 2025 low. We will also duly note that the weekly MACD in this later chart, did, indeed, diverge as well at the high, with the histogram tracing out bars below the zero line. So, if the MACD eventually did diverge, what is the point in noting the HYG divergence? Well, let's look at this second chart. This chart includes the SPY volume.
So, a primary tenet of the Bill Williams trading system is that market turns happen according to the following specific sequence: 1) First, somewhere out there in TraderLand (we might not know where), people make decisions about how they want their money allocated. 2) These decisions first affect the volume. 3) The change in volume then affects the price momentum because the increasing pace of price gains simply cannot be sustained without additional volume, hence money, to support it. 4) Finally, price is the last to change and reverse direction.
And isn't that what you see here?
Somebody has to comprise the Smart Money or the Big Money. The accounts have to be big enough to make a difference in large markets. In this case, the Smart Money is getting the highest yields with very little risk as the HYG ETF goes higher and higher in mid-2025. They are not only getting the highest yields, but they are also getting the added benefit of the price appreciation, too. They are really getting a two-for-one. This is Smart!
But the price appreciation in the HYG begins to drop off as the divergences begin, and this Smart Money cadre experience the difference. It begins to affect their decisions. They might temporarily move some money around, like the latter portion of 2025, when the divergences are first occurring, so money might be being moved into the SPY, which has not begun to deteriorate, yet. But - and this is critical - when their ETF makes no additional higher highs, and begins to make lower lows, they have reason to seriously think something has changed in the overall risk landscape. These decisions begin to affect volume. Just look at the SPY volume drop in March-through-September of 2026. Someone isn't playing ball anymore. It's not me or you. It's someone who leaves volume tracks in the SPY.
The SPY is at 781. Goldmann says SPY 800 is do-able. You think these people are saying, "yeah, I'm going to go all-in gangbusters on the 20-point difference? They are not stupid. They just got a two-fer. Isn't it much more reasonable that they are saying, "protect, protect, protect"? It likely is.
Eventually, this lower volume creates that momentum divergence in the MACD. The upturn can no longer be sustained. Is it short of Goldman's target? It is. Not my fault. Was it worth heeding these technical tracks as Bill Williams so clearly outlined? I think so.
While Goldman is calling for 800 or 830, and Tom Lee is crying for all to "buy the tech dip", and while Neely is calling for 100,000 Dow remember this: Neely did not tell you that - on the road to 100,000 Dow - the S&P was going to fall from 780 to 680, first. He simply did not. He may eventually be right. We don't know. But he sure left out one heck of a price excursion which may not be done yet.
What needs to be clear is that, for me, it was Bill Williams who first clarified how it is that the heavy momentum-laden ocean liner turns. We know it turns slowly. He was the one, who, for me & in writing clarified the links and the mechanism that makes it occur. The same is true at bottoms, perhaps only that bottoms might occur more quickly. So, again, credit for the original thinking goes to Bill Williams. I am trying to provide the best clear example I can find of how this happens so you might learn from it or better utilize it if you were unsure of what he was trying to convey. Bill sort-of required that we take it on his say so or his experience. A good example - while not proving anything definitively - makes faith a little less required.
And, yes, what you're thinking is correct. If one overreacts to the first divergence, money could be left on the table, money could be lost in the incorrect positions, etc. In other words, the trouble with any truly leading indicator is just that. To be useful, the indicator's turn must come before that of price. So even a great leading indicator, by definition, must be early. So, that becomes a question of what time frame one is trading or investing on, what leverage one has, etc. All that remains true. But it still seems helpful to have a clear example of the ship, in motion, actually making that lumbering wide-swinging turn.
Another aspect of potential leading indicators that was pointed out was the initial refusal of the NYSE advance/decline line to make new lows earlier in the year. I was clear that no major bear market I lived through had started without a divergence in the A/D line. So, let's look at how this played out.
Here you see the blue line is the cash $SPX index. Note it was making new highs into October. Yet, I had noted the new A/D line highs into August, and I pointed out when this measure began to crumble. The A/D line is the red & black line. Finally, the cash price caught up with the number of issues moving and began to fall. Now price and the issues are in gear to the downside, and the A/D line has actually, technically, made a lower swing low after making the wedge shape near the high from April into August. So, from this point it is possible for an actual bear market to begin, based on the history of other modern bear markets - and even some not-so-modern ones that analysts like Joe Granville and Marty Zweig used to comment on. Of course, huge retracements are possible at almost any time, but let's see how things go.
This is the second post since Friday. If you have not read the first one yet, you might like to read it now. Have an excellent rest of the day and weekend,
TraderJoe










